Search Archive
Search Justinian
Justinian's news stories

Mountain law ... Rich and colourful parade of judiciary in Mt Hagen ... Thousands of cases languish ... Remorseless giant LexisNexis swallows another case law analytics business ... Statelessness gets a handout ... Department of Immigration's unique interpretation of the Freedom of Information Act ... Lawyer's defamation appeal bites the dust  ... Read more ... 


Free Newsletter sign-up

 

Justinian Columnists

Fitch lets fly ... Our Man in Washington ... Republican anarchy ... The petulant presidency ... Wrecking ball through democratic institutions ... The conflicted cabinet ... Reinforcement from Fox News ... Foxes in the chook house ... Hanging Judge Gorsuch ... Read more ... 



Twitter

This form does not yet contain any fields.

    "What Simon Birmingham has been doing is absolutely fantastic. He has managed to un-mesh the terrible omelette that was created by the Gillard government, the Rudd government in terms of funding; he's undoing all that." 

    Senator Chris Back (Lib. WA) arguing that Catholic schools are getting a raw deal under Gonski 11. AM, ABC Radio, June 19, 2017  ... Read more ... 


    Justinian Featurettes

    Pauline Wright ... Ms Wright ... A busy bee, if ever there was one ... Pauline Wright, actor, swimmer, lifesaver, campaigner, playwright, passionate devotee to good causes ... And president of the Law Society of NSW ... Meet the person behind the whirlwind ... Read more ... 


    Justinian's archive

    Eldon's advice lands in court ... Was he a client or wasn’t he? ... Court of Appeal breathed life into a Brisbane solicitor's action against Lord Eldon over barristerial advice about failed NCA proceedings ... Sir Terence O'Rort reports ... From Justinian's archive, February 2004 ... Read more ... 


     

    « Hey, it's Christmas | Main | What's the world coming to? »
    Tuesday
    Dec232014

    Jackson to lead charge against ICAC

    David Jackson QC is to lead Margaret Cunneen's High Court case ... Major challenge to ICAC's future effectiveness ... Shroud of uncertainty hangs over pending reports ... ICAC to pick-up Cunneen's High Court costs 

    David Jackson: Cunneen asked him to takeover her High Court case

    WORD on the Street of Shame is that state prosecutor Margaret Cunneen has recruited David Jackson QC to do the job for her in the High Court. 

    It is understood that Arthur Moses, who has carried the flag for the deputy senior crown prosecutor in the application to put a stop to ICAC's inquiry into allegations that she perverted the course of justice, will be retained as part of Team Jacko.  

    ICAC has undertaken to pay Cunneen's costs of its High Court appeal. 

    The prosecutor also will have the benefit of costs orders from her success in the Court of Appeal. 

    ICAC is seeking to overturn the findings by the CA majority (Basten and Ward) that restricts the meaning of corrupt conduct.  

    It all hangs on s.8(1) and (2) of the ICAC Act 

    Section 8(1) defines corrupt conduct as: 

    "any conduct of any person ... that adversely affects, or that could adversely affect, either directly or indirectly, the honest or impartial exercise of official functions by any public official, any group or body of public officials or any public authority."   

    That seems wide enough. 

    Section 8(2) goes on to say that corrupt conduct is also: 

    "any conduct of any person that adversely affects, or that could adversely affect, either directly or indirectly, the exercise of official functions by any public official, any group of body of public officials or any public authority and which could involve ..." 

    a long list of offences of offences, including relevantly for these purposes, (g) perverting the course of justice  and (y) any conspiracy or attempt in relation to any of the above.

    What the CA majority did was import from s.8(1) "honest or impartial exercise of official functions" into s.8(2), even though it was not there. 

    Basten and Ward said that though the conduct alleged against Cunneen could constitute an attempt to pervert the course of justice as it was intended to dissuade a police officer from investigating the commission of an offence - nevertheless, her alleged conduct could not be said to cause the officer to act otherwise than honestly and impartially. 

    Conduct could only "adversely affect" public officials if they had actually acted improperly. 

    Such a finding puts into doubt the work done by ICAC in Operation Credo and around 50 percent of its work in Operation Spicer. 

    Credo was concerned with Australian Water Holdings Pty Ltd and whether people with an interest in that company obtained financial benefits by "adversely affecting" the official functions of the state government instrumentality, Sydney Water Corporation. 

    This involved billing for bogus expenses and inflated executive salaries, including by Eddie Obeid jnr and former Colin Biggers & Paisley managing partner Nick Di Girolamo. 

    Di Girolamo: ICAC findings hanging in the balanceDi Girolamo was described by counsel assisting ICAC, Geoffrey Watson, as, "an old-fashioned shyster, fraudster and barefaced liar". 

    According to Basten's view, if people at Sydney Water Corporation thought they were doing the right thing in paying these billed expenses, under an infrastructure agreement with AWH, then the investigation into Obeid jnr, Di Girolamo and others would be outside ICAC's ambit. 

    On this reasoning it's only if SWC did something improper could it be found that Obeid jnr and Di Girolamo acted corruptly. 

    Similarly, with operation Spicer, which looked at allegations that members of parliament received money from prohibited donors and failed to disclose those donations. 

    If a property developer, a prohibited donor, gave a bundle of money to an aspiring Liberal Party candidate, the Electoral Funding Authority may still have acted honestly and impartially in the exercise of its function, consequently on Basten's reasoning this too would be beyond ICAC's jurisdiction.  

    This is why the reports from the Credo and Spicer investigations now cannot be released by ICAC until the High Court has pronounced on whether the CA is correct or not. 

    See: current ICAC investigations 

    By engaging David Jackson to lead her High Court case Cunneen shows not only that she is determined to sink the investigation into the allegations concerning her conduct, but also to punch an everlasting hole in the corruption fighting ability of ICAC. 

    An array of crooks, spivs and graspers all over town will be cheering to the rafters. 

    Reader Comments (1)

    Its just all so convenient for the two major political parties. It could be so easily fixed by a very simple amendment to the legislation. But we all know that that will never happen. Instead, the politicians leave it up to the Judicial branch of Government, at public expense. As usual the lawyers have the last laugh.
    December 24, 2014 | Registered CommenterVictor Pigott
    Editor Permission Required
    You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.