
NSW solicitor Farshad Amirbeaggi has been given a lettucing by the NSW Court of Appeal for making a “careless” representation to the NSW costs assessor.
He claimed that his client had capacity, when in fact her capacity was the subject of an ongoing dispute in a separate Supreme Court litigation.
Amirbeaggi made this representation in the context of trying to get out of a costs assessment, which would force him to justify the over $1.2 million that he had charged his client in the years 2018-2019.
Interestingly, this is not the only time that Amirbeaggi’s seemingly high legal fees have come into the spotlight.
While declining to refer him to the Bureau de Spank, last year Supremo Justice Elizabeth Peden noted how his bill of $1.3 million appeared disproportionate to the ultimate judgment award of $73,252, especially given the small size and simplicity of the dispute (see further, Wrong Court).
The year before, Amirbeaggi’s law shop, Yates Beaggi, was ordered to refund nearly $100,000 after a dispute with a former client over an excessive legal bill.

In this case, a complaint made against Amirbeaggi for gross overcharging was dismissed after he entered into a deed of settlement, the terms of which have not been disclosed.
Consequently, the disciplinary action concerns not the costs themselves, but rather the misleading letter he sent to the costs assessor.
On appeal, Mark Leeming JA, Anna Mitchelmore JA and Derek Price AJA came to a unanimous finding of unsatisfactory professional conduct.
Their decision confirms the initial finding made by the NSW Law Society’s Bureau de Spank, which was also affirmed on appeal by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.
The client in question, who legally cannot be named, has been caught in a nasty trusts dispute with her brothers since 2018.
In July 2018, a NSW Trustee and Guardian was appointed to manage her financial affairs, after an application was lodged by the client’s mother and brothers.
The client, represented by Amirbeaggi, sought to quash this decision in the NSW Supreme Court.
While the dispute over the guardianship appointment was ongoing, in March 2019 the client’s Guardian applied for a costs assessment of Amirbeaggi’s million-dollar legal bill.
A costs assessment would force Amirbeaggi to produce submissions justifying an amount of over $1.2 million that he had charged his client over the past 13 months.
However, if the Supreme Court were to find that his client had capacity, the orders appointing the Guardian would be set aside, and the costs assessment therefore would not proceed.
It is against this background that Amirbeaggi and his client attended a directions hearing held in April 2019 before Geoff Lindsay J. The hearing regarded the client’s financial management and the appointment of the Guardian.

In those proceedings, Amirbeaggi sought to obtain a final hearing on the question of the client’s capacity as soon as possible. He employed senior counsel Mark Ashurst to advance submissions that the client had capacity, based on an expert report provided by Professor John Watson (not from the Sherlock canon).
Watson’s report described how the client suffered from chronic pain and, at times, drug-seeking behaviour, including abuse of major psychoactive drugs.
There had been times when the client likely had impaired cognitive function, and if she were to revert to using high quantities of psychoactive drugs, intervention would likely be required.
Ashurst SC’s submissions of the client’s capacity were not accepted by Lindsay J, who repeatedly stated that it remained a live issue. HH further refused to set down a date for final hearing, instead directing that further expert evidence be adduced, and that the proceedings resume the following month.
Whilst the capacity question remained unresolved, time was also ticking on the Guardian’s costs assessment application and Amirbeaggi’s deadline for submissions was quickly approaching.
Against this background, Amirbeaggi sought a stay of the costs assessment. In a letter dated May 15, 2019 to the costs assessor, he stated that in the April directions hearing Lindsay J had noted there was “no doubt” the client had capacity.
In the disciplinary proceedings, both the Committee at first instance, and the Tribunal on appeal, found that this letter amounted to a misrepresentation constituting unsatisfactory professional conduct under s.296 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law.
In his second appeal to the Court of Appeal, Amirbeaggi particularised 10 errors on the part of the Tribunal.
The Law Society conceded that the Tribunal erred by concluding Amirbeaggi needed to qualify the letter, but this was not found to be material by the bench, who otherwise upheld the Tribunal’s decision.
Leeming JA described Amirbeaggi’s representation as a “substantially distorted description of the contested directions hearing”, with Mitchelmore JA (Price AJA agreeing) describing it as “careless”.
It did not matter that he used the word “noted” rather than “stated”, as the representation of his client’s capacity was still absolute.
In writing to the costs assessor, Amirbeaggi placed himself in a position of direct conflict between his self-interest and the obligations to his client.
His conduct fell short of the standard of competence and diligence that a member of the public is entitled to expect of a reasonably competent lawyer.
The seriousness of the misstatement is heightened given that the letter was written to a third party, who otherwise did not have knowledge of the ongoing legal proceedings.
It further did not matter that Amirbeaggi based his letter on his genuine recollection of events.
For the saga, Amirbeaggi has been issued a caution.