
Struck-off NSW lawyer, Cesar Montenegro, has spent the better part of a decade fighting his removal from the jam roll by the Court of Appeal in 2015.
His latest petition, an application for judicial review of LPAB’s refusal of his application for re-admission, was recently thrown out by a unanimous judgment of Adamson JA, Ball JA and Price AJA in the NSW Court of Appeal.
Among other conclusions, the decision could be seen to validate the LPAB’s incomplete record-keeping, as the board’s failure on one occasion to record a declaration of a conflict of interest was found to not invalidate its decision to refuse to issue a compliance certificate.
Montenegro’s troubles began in the early 2000s, when he racked up a string of criminal offences. His activities included drink driving, possession of a false driver licence, urinating on a door, damaging his girlfriend’s car windows, and destroying a toilet block.
Montenegro disclosed his previous criminal charges when he was admitted to practice in 2008.
However, his offending resurfaced in 2014, when Montenegro attempted to join the NSW Bar, whereby his previous disclosures were found to be inadequate.
Rejected by the Bar Association, Montenegro went back to the Law Society in the hopes of obtaining a practising certificate for 2015.
However, his application was similarly rejected on the grounds of inadequate disclosure.
This decision was set aside by Stephen Campbell J of the Supremes (see further: Memory Problems), who gave Montenegro a ticket to practice with a few attached conditions.
However, Campbell’s judgment was ultimately negated by the Court of Appeal, which, in late 2015, ordered Montenegro to be struck from the roll for failing to be of good fame and character.
Montenegro has since made numerous unsuccessful attempts to re-join the trade. His application for special leave to the High Court was refused, as was his subsequent application for a compliance certificate for re-admission in December 2017 – a decision which he tried to appeal but later dropped.
The present case concerns his second application for a compliance certificate, which was rejected by LPAB in June 2024, refusing also to review its decision in October 2024.
Interestingly, the former solicitor did not request an appeal by way of re-hearing (which is possible under s 26(1) of the Uniform Law) but rather chose to seek judicial review under s.69 of the Supreme Court Act.
Montenegro launched two main arguments to support his case. The first (encompassing grounds 1-4 of his appeal), related to the handling of a conflict of interest which was declared at the first LPAB meeting by Jennifer Ball, a Clayton Utz partner and Law Society councillor, at the first LPAB meeting.
The second (ground 5 of his appeal) rests on what he considers the LPAB’s failure to consider the mandatory relevant consideration of his law-related experience post-expulsion.
Unfortunately, the former solicitor did not get to raise these arguments directly before the court, as he was absent from the final hearing due to illness. This turn of events occurred in circumstances when Montenegro was already trying to get out of attending court in person.
The Saturday before the final hearing, he had sent an application to attend via Audio Visual Link, citing that his place of residence was more than 20km from the Supreme Court registry. This was rejected by the court on Monday, the day before trial.
About 15 minutes later, Montenegro tried again, stating that he was a person with significant disabilities which affect his mobility and capacity to travel. He attached three medical reports from April, May and July 2026.
The court again rejected his application, but the next morning at 5.37 am, the former solicitor emailed that he had fallen severely ill and was unable to attend court.
Proceeding with the hearing despite Montenegro’s absence, the three justices held that each of his submissions must be rejected.
One of Montenegro’s arguments was that his self-representation in various proceedings, including those commenced by him against his family, amounts to legal experience since expulsion, and thus is a factor that must be considered by the LPAB.
The court found that whilst this self-representation may demonstrate legal skill to an extent, it does not necessarily demonstrate an applicant’s character vis-à-vis a legal professional’s duties to the court and the public, which was held to be the purpose of rule 14(1)(d) of the Admission Rules.
In any event, the justices found that the LPAB is allowed to consider the weight it should place on any given factor in an application. Here, the information provided by Montenegro was not completely excluded, meaning that there was no error of law.
Montenegro’s arguments concerning Jennifer Ball and her conflict of interest were similarly fruitless.
The Court found that it did not matter that the LPAB minutes did not specify the reason for the conflict, or that they did not record Ms Ball declaring her conflict in the second decision in October, especially given evidence that the conflict was in fact declared.
The court then drew on Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority to conclude that this “oversight”, in any event, would not vitiate the Board’s decision, as this was not the legislative intent of the record-keeping requirements.
The court further found that there had been no denial of procedural fairness, even though Ms Ball did not recuse herself from the meeting and merely abstained from voting.
The appeal judges found that, considering the nature of LPAB and the question that it had to decide, there was no realistic possibility her presence would stifle the debate or inhibit the other members from reaching their own conclusions.
Their Hons found that any argument of apprehended bias could not succeed.