News from Rome

Letter from Rome    Monday, October 12, 2026

Constitution stretched as Meloni regime races to the bottom ... Bid to outdo the uber-right ... Crackdown on migrant children in Italian classrooms ... The President weighs in and gets ticked off ... Silvana Olivetti from our Rome Desk

In Italy, pressure from the new further-right wing party, National Future, has the right-wing Meloni government testing the boundaries of constitutional protections in proposed changes to laws affecting migrants.

Prime Minister Meloni exposed the delicate power balance between the Head of State and the Leader of the Government last month when she all but called grandfatherly Italian President Sergio Mattarella a hypocrite.

This insult, apart from breaching convention, could be counter-productive.

The  Italian President is not a mere rubber stamp for government legislation. He or she may delay signing legislation when they have concerns about its Constitutional validity, and can ask for changes.

The drama occurred in late September when Prime Minister Meloni announced new policies affecting the children of migrants.

The first was that the number of non-Italian-speaking children in each class should not exceed 30% of the total number of students.

The excess students would have to travel to another school. She also announced a ban on girls wearing the hijab or niqab to school.

The third part of the policy package was directed at the parents or carers of those foreign students who were struggling to learn Italian.

The parents would be required to go to adult language schools to study the language. If the parents didn’t go, they would be liable for fines of hundreds of euros, and their non-compliance could lead to the intervention of child welfare authorities taking the children away.

Under the umbrella: President Mattarella

The next day, President Mattarella, speaking at an event marking the start of the Italian school year, said that schools should be a place fostering integration, not segregation.

This apparently offended Ms Meloni. She went on television armed with what she believed was a “gotcha” moment to embarrass Mattarella.

She said that 35  years ago, when Mattarella was a Government Minister, he had introduced a rule that there should be no more than five non-Italian-speaking students in every class.

Meloni said, “You see, Mattarella did the same things that we have”.

Article 34

Mattarella has maintained a dignified silence, but there have been two responses.

An historian has come to his aid in relation to the 1990 policy. Also, behind-the-scenes discussions have led to amendments to the proposed legislation.

In relation to the 1990 policy, Stefano Musso, a professor of contemporary history at the University of Turin,  said that Mattarella’s 1990 policy had its origin in the huge  post-war internal migration from the south of Italy  to the north.

The southern migrants spoke dialect, not standard Italian. All the children of migrants were lumped together in a single class.

Professor Musso said that he himself experienced this as a child of southern migrants. He said that Mattarella’s policy of 35 years ago was in fact a policy to stop the segregation of non-Italian-speaking students, not an attack on them.

Now the draft policy forwarded to the President a few days later clearly took into consideration Mattarella’s concerns about its Constitutionality.

It was reported that the changes followed “a long conversation with the head of state” (Corriere Della Sera, “Il Colle emana il decreto Scuola, parte l’iter in Parlamento”, October 1, 2026).

The Italian Constitution clearly states that “Schools are open to everyone” (Article 34).

The revised proposals admit the need for exceptions. Students won’t be shipped off to schools that are too far away, and carers who are too busy with work and/or caring duties to go to language colleges won’t be fined.

The ban on the hijab or niqab has been replaced by a generic ban on face coverings. The implied threat of children being placed in State care has been withdrawn. Children of diplomats will be exempt from the proposal.

Even so, the proposed policy has had many critics. During the weeks after the announcement, many Italian schools, with the support of teachers, parents and students, have hung banners outside the schools stating  “Here no-one is a foreigner”.

What will happen next?

The proposal now goes to the Parliament, which has 60 days to examine, propose amendments and vote on the legislation. The fractured opposition parties do not have the numbers to defeat it.

What the Constitutional Court will make of the legislation is another matter, given the  Constitutional guarantees of access to education and prohibitions on discrimination on the grounds of religion and race.

Practically speaking, the proposal to send parents to adult education classes to learn Italian also faces challenges. The national adult education system that teaches Italian to adults, set up in the wake of the post-war internal migration, has a current waiting list of about 8,000 people.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *