Longstanding barrister hammered for failing to produce documents on time ... Civil Contempt ... Fine of $25,000 ... Sydney chambers chasing payment of fees ... Inconsistent penalties for failure to comply ... Accountant's bicycling accident ... Barrister hires solicitor who will brief him ... Mae Milne reports on extraordinary developments

Sydney-based barrister Philip Bates has been found by the NSW Supreme Court to have committed multiple acts of civil contempt by failing to comply with court orders requiring the production of financial documents.
The finding of contempt by David Hammerschlag CJ in Eq occurs in the context of litigation between Bates and his former chambers, Sir Anthony Mason Chambers, which is seeking recovery of unpaid floor fees in excess of $112,000.
The Hammer followed up his civil contempt findings on November 5 by spanking Bates with a fine of $25,000, plus costs.
The Fin Review has more on the penalty and its fallout.
Bates denies his liability to cough up the coins, claiming an “equitable set-off” with money that he asserts to have lent and advanced to his floor – an argument which bumped the matter from the Dizzo to the equitable division of the NSW Supremes.
Before the case was transferred, Robert Hollo DCJ made orders compelling Bates to produce business activity statements and income tax returns for the years 2014 to 2023 by March 9, 2026.
Although the orders were made by consent, Bates knew then and there that he would not be able to comply with the request: the last time he had lodged a BAS and tax return was in 2016.
Incidentally, for all their legal expertise, this is hardly the first time a big-name barrister has failed to lodge their tax returns promptly (see also Cummins & Ors).
In spite of repeated requests from chambers, by May 18, 2026, Bates had still not provided the documents. The Registrar in Equity thus made an additional order that Bates must comply with the original court order by June 15, 2026.
Some more months later, by September 2, 2026, Bates had still not provided his documents. Chambers thus filed a Notice of Motion, attaching a Statement of Charge that Bates had failed to comply with court orders.
Although the Statement of Charge contained an embarrassing typo regarding dates, one which was not missed by The Hammer, it seems to have finally spurred our errant barrister to disclose his financials on September 26, 2026. The accompanying letter gave no explanation for his default.
Failing to produce documents is nothing new – the Australian Law Reform Commission in 1999 found that in almost all studies of litigation, discovery is the procedure most open to abuse.
In the circumstances, a finding of contempt is a harsh spanking for poor Phil, who has been around the traps for a long time. Of course, failure to pay chamber’s fees is an offence of the utmost gravity.
Judge Judith Gibson (as she then was) in Kemble v Gate Gourmet Services Pty Ltd (here and here) gave examples of cases where parties hadn’t produced documents, with inconsistent consequences.
“I briefly note another matter which arose for discussion in the course of oral submissions, but which was not relied upon by the plaintiff as being an exceptional circumstance, namely the failure of the first defendant to provide any documents in answer to a series of subpoenas issued both before and during these proceedings on issues relevant to liability.
The consequence for a party who has failed to comply with orders for production of documents on discovery has been dealt with by the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Palavi v Radio 2UE Sydney Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 264, Palavi v Queensland Newspapers Pty Ltd [2012] NSWCA 182 and Clark v State of New South Wales [2012] NSWCA 139 (see also Cameron and Liberman, in ‘Destruction of documents before proceedings commence: what is the court to do?’ (2003) 27 Melbourne University Law Rev 273).
It may appear inconsistent that one litigant who complies at least in part with discovery obligations can be penalised by the loss of part or all of the cause of action, while another litigant who totally fails to answer a subpoena in personal injury proceedings (where there is no discovery) should suffer no penalty at all …”
Bates tried his best to get out of trouble, arguing that his non-compliance was inadvertent and not wilful, because he was inhibited by circumstances beyond his control.
HH found these arguments to be “factually inaccurate, without merit and disingenuous”.
While Bates had taken some steps to meet with his tax agent, he had proposed an initial meeting on March 10 – after the date required for compliance with the original court orders.
His tax agent, in any event, was unable to assist with this request, because he was scaling down his practice and didn’t want to take on more work.
Poor old Bates then solicited the aid of a second accountant who, unfortunately, was also unable to provide timely assistance because of an unfortunate bicycle accident in July.
The court held that the bicycling misadventure was not, in fact, the cause of Bates’ delay, which was conscious and wilful, and so an act of civil contempt.

In reaching this conclusion, The Hammer drew particular attention to the fact that Bates is an experienced barrister, who knew that he would not be able to provide the requested documents in time.
Nonetheless, and in the face of repeated requests on behalf of his erstwhile chambers, Bates provided no explanation for his delay in document production. Nor did he provide at least partial disclosure of the documents that he did have.
As an ancillary issue, HH further noted Bates represented himself as counsel while he was also a material witness in the substantive proceedings, and a witness in the present motion, so he was in breach of r.101(d) of the Legal Profession Uniform Conduct (Barristers) Rules (2015).
“The concept of him employing a solicitor who then briefs him in his own case is, to put it mildly, of concern, from the point of view of each of them.”
Australian Continuing Legal Education Centre Pty Ltd is the corporate entity that conducts Sir Anthony Mason Chambers.
Australian Continuing Legal Education Centre Pty Limited v Philip Bates