Theodora’s beat

Theodora    Friday, March 20, 2026

Hands up for Guv'nor of Taswegia ... A couple of suspects ... Death tribute in Bar News ignores unhappy details ... Out and About with Theodora

Vice Regal News

It is anticipated that Her Excellency, The Hon Barbara Baker, Governor of Tasmania, will finish up at Government House on June 14, at the end of her five-year stint.

Barbara was a judge on the Federal Circuitous Court before she landed the job at the Gothic pile on Lower Domain Road.

The local Bar ‘n’ Grill is alive with scuttlebutt about who will get the gig, and naturally lawyers think it is a position that should be theirs.

Names in the mix include the famed foodie Stephen Estcourt, a justice of the Van Diemen’s Land Supreme Court, and Major General Aziz (Greg) Melick AO KC.

In 2017, Estcourt was sworn in as an Administrator of the Government of Tasmania, so it’s a small step up to Guv’nor.

Maybe for the taste of the big decision-makers, Otto Abetz and Godly Guy Barnett, the judge might be a bit on the soft-left, squishy end of the political spectrum.

In July 2011, Justinian had the happy duty to report that Estcourt was awarded $110,000 ($65,000 for the plaintiff and $45,000 for his lawyers) in a defamation settlement with the Hobart Mercury.

Melbourne barrister Laurence Maher devised the winning imputation:

“Unlike a range of senior Tasmanian political and legal figures and other persons who had co-operated with the Tasmania Police by being (or agreeing to be) interviewed by the Tasmania Police, which was conducting an investigation in relation to new allegations of corruption involving persons in the higher echelons of Tasmania’s political and legal circles, the plaintiff, who was at the centre of that police probe, had declined to be interviewed by the police conducting the investigation, thereby concealing relevant information from and obstructing that investigation.”

HH Stehen Estcourt … a contender

Estcourt’s damages dwarfed a previous defamation wrangle involving Tasmanian lawyers, Howes v “Clock Face” Gunson – two solicitors who had a stoush during a dinner at the Tasmanian Club.

A jury awarded Howes damages of $1,500.

If our memory serves correctly, Stephen Estcourt acted for another governor on his way out the door, the notorious Richard Butler, who resigned after a chaotic stint marked by arrogance, abuse of staff, and unattractive vice-regal behaviour.

The Premier, Paul (The Burst Sav) Lennon, arranged for an ex gratia payout of $650,000, which shocked and dismayed the populace. Here are the Cabinet documents dealing with Butler’s termination.

If Melick is appointed to Government House, it would be another bauble for the ageing Hobart silk, already weighed down by ribbons and garlands. Most recently, he led the campaign to restore KCs for Apple Isle briefs.

The most recent report we had about Greg was his birching by the Full Feds for his reasoning in an AAT decision, which was described by their Hons as “spare, if not perfunctory … [and having] manifest defects”.

In November last year, Paul Keating described Melick as a “dope”.

Quite possibly, Godly Guy might prefer to see a cleric installed at Guv House – maybe Rev Michael Jensen, from the burn-in-hell Sydney branch of the Anglican Church.

Jensen is a high-profile opponent of marriage equality and women taking leadership roles in the church. Inexplicably, someone invited him to deliver a sermon for the service at St David’s Cathedral to mark the opening of the 2026 Tasmanian law year.

Cockroach in the accolade

Flipping through the latest edition of Bar News (NSW version) in the dentist’s waiting room, I found a generous tribute for the former and now deceased barrister Paul Coe.

He was described as a “trailblazing advocate” who was the first Aboriginal person to study law at the University of NSW; co-founder of the Aboriginal Legal Aid Service in Redfern; and one of the key people to establish the Aboriginal Tent Embassy in Canberra.

Coe: unfit

He took a thoroughly unsuccessful case to the High Court, arguing that colonisation was contrary to Aboriginal sovereignty.

He was a man of “unwavering resilience, empowerment, courage, perseverance, and passion”.

Clearly, a strong advocate for the Aboriginal cause with lasting achievements to his name.

While panegyrics are destined to dwell on the bristling achievements and the rosy upside, there is still an obligation to provide a rounded portrait of the deceased.

In this case, what was missing was the tiny detail that the Bar Council had brought proceedings against Coe in the Legal Services Tribunal, resulting in his removal from the jam roll in 1997.

He had sworn an affidavit, in his own family law proceedings, he knew to be false – claiming his income was $70,000 when he knew it was $150,000.

He was doomed. He appealed, but the NSWCA didn’t throw him a line.

That was not the end of it. The Sydney Morning Herald reported in November 2003 that once again Paul was under investigation, having allegedly continued to practice as a barrister without a ticket.

At the time, Bret Walker was the President of the Bar ‘n’ Grill. He told the newspaper:

“The full attention of the peak organ of the bar is given to cases like this … Is he practising law without a licence? That he lacks a licence is clear. The question is, is he practising law? That matter is under investigation. It would be unfair to pre-judge the outcome.”

An investigator into the affairs of the Metropolitan Local Aboriginal Land Council found that Coe had been appointed to offer “legal advice as a consultant” and had received fees of $3,000.

President Walker said practising law while ticketless could well be a summary offence punishable in the Local Court.

“Somebody who was convicted of such an offence would find it difficult on any subsequent re-application to be admitted as a legal practitioner. If they had those hopes for the future, this would be a big cockroach in the ointment.”

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *