Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Balkan intrigues ... Old coppers stagger into the Croatian Six inquiry ... 15-year jail terms in 1980 for alleged terrorism ... Miscarriage of justice under review ... Verballing ... Loading-up ... Old fashioned detective "work" ... Evidence so far ... Hamish McDonald reports ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


Splitting heirs ... How to get rid of the Royals – a Republican tours Orstraya … Underneath their robes – sexual harassment on the bench … Credit card fees – so tricky that only economists know what to do … Muted response to Drumgold vindication … Vale Percy Allan ... Read on ... 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Blue sky litigation ... Another costly Lehrmann decision ... One more spin on the never-never ... Arguable appeal discovered in the bowels of the Gazette of Law & Journalism ... Odious litigants ... Could Lee J have got it wrong on the meaning of rape? ... Calpurnia reports from the Defamatorium ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian's Bloggers

Online incitements ... Riots in English cities fed by online misinformation about refugees ... Policing and prosecution policies ... Fast and furious processing of offenders ... Online Safety Act grapples with new challenges ... Increased policing of speech on tech platforms ... Hugh Vuillier reports from London ... Read more >> 

"Mistakes of law or fact are a professional inevitability for judges, tribunal members and administrative decision makers."  

Paul Brereton, Commissioner of the National Corruption Concealment Commission, downplaying the Inspector's finding of bias and procedural unfairness with his conflicted involvement in the decision making about Robodebt referrals ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Vale Percy Allan AM ... Obit for friend and fellow-traveller ... Prolific writer on economics and politics ... Public finance guru ... Technocrat with humanity and broad interests ... Theatre ... Animals ... Art ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

A triumph for Victorian morality ... Ashton v Pratt ... In the sack with Dick Pratt ... Meretricious sexual services renders contract void on public policy grounds ... Justice Paul Brereton applies curious moral standard ... A whiff of hypocrisy ... Doubtful finding ... Artemus Jones reporting ... From Justinian's Archive, January 24, 2012 ... Who knew the NACC commissioner had strong views on the sanctity of marriage ... Read more ... 


 

 

« Old Mates Act | Main | Washington notebook »
Saturday
Mar092013

Chestnut in the fire

The Map of Tasmania ... Madge Marron birched again, this time by the CJ-in-waiting ... Traffic Act trauma ... New Supremos  

Alan Blow: from Sydney to HobartI was a bit upset that Madge Reg Marron wasn't among the cluster of new appointments to the Tas Supremes. 

The Skittle's office announced that Alan Blow, Sydney raised and bred, was to be the CJ, and that Stephen Estcourt QC and Madge Robert Pearce are to be new Supremos. 

Simon Cooper and Simon Brown become madges.

Cooper's appointment is well overdue - as head of the Resource Planning and Development Commission he was in the bad books of Premier (The Burst Sav) Lennon, who meddled and tried to short circuit the Gunns Pulp Mill approval process. 

The Tasmanian Times reminds us that the former attorney general Steve Kons was forced to resign after misleading parliament about shredded documents recommending Cooper's appointment as a magistrate five years ago. 

TT readers also former clients also make their unhappy comments about the new Supreme Court appointees. 

Madge Marron's record on traffic cases also may have disadvantaged him with the selectors, particularly as the CJ-in-waiting has just issued a punishing judgment booting one of the Chestnut's decision in a tricky driving licence drama. 

Blow described the decision to grant George Andrew Bushby a restricted driving licence as "extraordinary", adding that the Chestnut had been "extremely gullible". 

See reasons

Bushby's provisional licence was suspended for three months as a result of an accumulation of demerit points. 

He came before Marron pleading that since he's a real estate salesman he needs his car for seven days a week between 8am and 8pm. 

Estcourt: joins the Tas SupremesThe Chestnut granted him the restricted licence after some creative interpretation of the Vehicle and Traffic Act which requires that a disqualification can be set aside if the magistrate is satisfied it would impose "severe and unusual hardship".  

Bushby produced a letter from his boss saying that his employment would be "jeopardised" if he lost his licence. 

Marron granted an adjournment so the hapless real estate spruiker could go and get a better letter. 

This did the trick because he returned to court with a second missive that said the lad's employment would be "terminated" if he did not get a restricted licence. 

Bushby already had been twice disqualified from driving and there was a shortage of evidence that he faced severe or unusual hardship. Blow said: 

"I suppose I have to accept that the learned magistrate was approaching his duties conscientiously. It follows therefore that he was extremely gullible on this occasion in accepting the letter." 

Marron: conscientiousHe also gave the prosecutor a whack for allowing the letter to be tendered without hauling the real estate boss into the box for cross-examination. 

Last time the Chestnut featured in dispatches from The Map it was Crawford CJ giving him a birching for another traffic case, in which the magistrate erred no fewer than 12 times.  

On that occasion the Chestnut was being mean to a speeding driver and convicted her after conducting the case like an inquisition. 

Among the tiny errors identified by the CJ were that Madge Marron found the charge proved without any admissiblele evidence to support the finding; and telling the accused that the charge would be found proved unless she gave evidence. 

In 2010 The Examiner reported that someone suspected of being the Chestnut was caught driving 42 km/h over the limit. 

Such an experience can often cause a judicial officer to go either quite hard or unduly soft on people charged with similar offences. 

Last December The Mercury was carrying on because the Supreme Court upheld the sixth appeal against Reg in 12 months.  

Again, Crawford thought Reg's sentence in a driving drama was "manifestly inadequate". 

He's given Stacey Amanda Bessell a suspended jail term and 63 hours' community service for two counts of driving while disqualified. 

According to The Mercurial, Bessell, 32, has a criminal record of 242 offences including driving matters, offences of violence and dishonesty and her latest crimes breached the conditions of a three-month suspended jail sentence. 

The Supreme Court huffed about "unwarranted leniency". 

Frankly, these attacks on the Launceston Chestnut have gone too far. 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.