Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Unread emails ... Family law barrister in Adelaide neglects to attend to emails ... Reminders to renew her ticket studiously ignored ... Unravelling chaos ... Trials invalidated ... Liability of Law Society and Conduct Commissioner ... Breach of statutory requirement ... Damages ... From our Team on the Torrens ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


An Australian Abroad ... An essay with pictures … Egypt and the Grand Museum … No end to the antiquities … Down the Nile on a dahabiya … Tombs and temples … Paris and industrial-scale tourism … The Yarts & Kulture ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Annihilation of the now ...Trump's campaign of destruction ... Fake emergencies ... Pointless and farcical executive orders ... Gangsterism ... Looting ... Corruption ... Shakedowns ... White rage ... Christian nationalism ... Roger Fitch unloads ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Tasmanis's Lieutenant Guv (and CJ) Christopher Shenanigans is unlikely to decide the consitiutional impass ... The current guv'nor, former Circuit Court judge and family lawyer Barbara Baker returns to Guv House next week ... Labor hates the Greens and is unlikely to form a coalition government ... Another election looks likely as the numbers for both sides are brittle and unreliable ... However, Baker can ask the Labor leader to test his numbers. 

Justinian's Bloggers

Letter from London ... Weather report ... Starmer sinking ... Farage rising ... Fake law firm ... Fake cases ...  NHS employee cleans up with woke case for hurt feelings ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt files from Blighty ... Read more >> 

"In its self-image, Australia has changed from a nation of tough, resilient Anzacs to a snowflake society of victims. This can be seen in the rise of identity politics, cancel culture, trigger warnings, unconscious bias, workplace Broderickism, LGBTQIA+ pleading, colonisation impacts, hidden disabilities and welfare dependency. Hurt feelings, offensive words, micro-aggressions, workload stress and anxiety now form the basis of workers compensation claims."

Mark Latham MLC - a dissenting statement in a parliamentary report on proposed changes to workers compensation law ... May 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Zeilgeist litigation ... Matt Collins KC on live-streaming of high-profile trials ... Social media nightmare ... Abuse of barristers ... Chilling emails ... Trials as a form of public entertainment ... Courts sleepwalking into a dangerous zone ... Framework needed to balance competing interests ... Paper delivered to Australian Lawyers Alliance Conference ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Justice Jeff Shaw's bingle ... Supreme Court judge's drink-drive experience ... Cars damaged in narrow Sydney street ... Touch driving ... Missing blood sample ... Equality before the law may not apply to judges ... Judges behind the wheel ... From Justinian's Archive ... November 4, 2004 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Solicitors short changed on ethics | Main | Sick of silks »
Wednesday
May042011

Doctors say Maurice Blackburn has a temperature 

Compensation law firm in High Court fighting compensation claim by former salaried partner ... Harassment and humiliation led to anxiety, depression and agoraphobia ... 30 percent psychological impairment ... Can findings of medical panel be challenged?

The High Court yesterday (Tuesday, May 2) heard a challenge by Maurice Blackburn seeking to test the conclusiveness of findings by medical panels in personal injury cases.

Vic Appeals had rejected an argument by the venerable compensation law shop that it should be allowed to bring evidence inconsistent with findings by a medical panel in a case involving one of the firm's former salaried partners.

The respondent, Fiona Brown, claims that for 11 months in 2003 she was "systematically undermined, harassed and humiliated" by a fellow employee at the firm.

She suffered severe anxiety, depression, eczema, headaches and agoraphobia.

In 2006 WorkCover referred her to a medical panel, which found there was a 30 percent psychiatric impairment, and that her condition was "permanent".

Under s.134AB(15 of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic) this was deemed to be a serious injury, giving rise to a claim of damages at common law.

In its defence Maurice Blackburn Cashman (as it then was) denied that Ms Brown had suffered injury.

She said that the law shop was precluded from going behind the opinion of the medical panel.

Prior to the trial in the County Court, Judge Paul Lacava referred the case to the Court of Appeal.

Ashley, Mandie and Ross held that the appellant was prohibited in the proceedings from asserting or leading evidence inconsistent with the opinion of the medical panel.

VicAppeals relied on s.68(4) of the Accident Compo Act:

"For the purposes of determining any question or matter, the opinion of a medical panel on a medical question referred to the medical panel is to be adopted and applied by any court, body or person and must be accepted as final and conclusive by any court, body or person."

Maurice Blackburn argued that the Court of Appeal was wrong in holding that as a result of the combination of s.68(4) and s.134AB(15) of the ACA the opinion of the medical panel has the result that for the purposes of the trial of the damages claim:

  • Ms Brown will be deemed to suffer serious injury both as to pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity;
  • The opinion of the panel with its "mandated serious injury consequences must be adopted and applied at the trial;
  • The law shop is not entitled to put in issue the fact that at the time the panel gave its opinion Ms Brown suffered serious injury, namely a permanent severe mental disturbance or order.

It appears that the insurer is driving this appeal for Maurice Blackburn, otherwise it most likely would have been settled long ago.

See transcript

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.