Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

The law and its miracles ... Party allies selected for judicial elevation in Qld ... Justice Jenni Hill's brother ... More entries for the Golden Tortoise award ... Federal Court muddles the maths, again ... Theodora reports ... Read more >>

Politics Media Law Society


Rupert World ... Lord Moloch’s pal Doug the Diva – driving Washington spare … News UK’s model for unionism … What next for the Washington Post? … Concealed coal lobbyists running an anti-Teal campaign … More corruption busting for Stinging Nettle … The litigation industry spawned by Lehrmann ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Party time for Dicey ... Heydon's book - a pathway to rehabilitation ... The predatory man and the clever intellect - all wrapped up in the one person ... Academic tome and cancel agenda ... Despite the plaudits the record of abuse doesn't vanish ... Book launch with young associates at a safe distance ... Procrustes thinks out loud ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


The Lubyanka ... Bullying investigation into former Federal Court judge goes nowhere ... "Complaint unsubstantiated" ... Phew! ... Recommendations about staff education ... Nothing recommended for judicial induction ... More >> 

 

Justinian's Bloggers

Governance turmoil at Tiny Town Law Society ... Night of the long knives ... Lakeside in Canberra ... ACT Law Society upheaval over governance changes ... Bodies carted out of the council room ... Blood on the carpet ... Fraught litigation another distraction ... From Gang Gang ... Read more >> 

"We're in unchartered territory here. A Pope hasn't died before during an Australian election campaign."  

Jane Norman, National Affairs Correspondent, ABC News ... April 21, 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Letter from Rome ... Judges on strike ... Too much "reform" ... Berlusconi legacy ... Referendum on the way ... Constitutional court inflames the Meloni regime with decision on boat people ... Insults galore ... Silvana Olivetti reports ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Tea is for Tippy ... Life of a tiffstaff ... Bright, ambitious and, when it comes to the crucial things, hopeless ... Milking the glory of the gig ...  Introducing Tippy, our new blogger filing from within the concrete cage at Queens Square ... From Justinian's Archive, March 15, 2010 ...  Read more >> 


 

 

« Wymyn baristas | Main | Supreme Court of Riverview »
Friday
Feb222013

Fair trials for lawyers

Staying criminal trials in the hope that legal aid will stump-up more money ... Solicitorless in a fused world ... Too much work for barristers ... More lawyers needed for cases that are not complex 

Lasry J: stay a while

IN the past week, two criminal trials have been brought to a halt in Victoria because counsel were going to be without instructing solicitors for the duration of the trials. 

New Vic legal Aid regulations, aimed at reducing a $3.1 million deficit, dictate that an instructing solicitor will only be provided for two and half days of the trial. 

See The rich tapestry of the law 

Last Friday, Justice Lasry's court heard that Andrew Jackson, counsel for the accused in an attempted murder case, was forced to head on down to the local magistrates court to locate his instructing solicitor. 

Despite admitting that "in the context of trials in this Court, [the case] could not be regarded as complex", Lasry was hesitant to allow Jackson to continue to fly solo. 

Although Lasry concluded he could not provide a remedy to the situation under s.197 of the Criminal Procedure Act, he ordered a temporary stay under the guise of an accused's right to a fair trial. 

HH said proceedings would not resume until counsel has a solicitor for the entire trial. 

His reasons provided an exhaustive list of tasks that differentiate a solicitor from a barrister both prior to and during the trial, including: 

  • The briefing of counsel, by then armed with a thorough knowledge of the case and an understanding as how a trial could or should be conducted; 
  • Being present at discussion concerning whether the client should plead guilty or not guilty; 
  • Consulting with counsel on how to most effectively cross-examine prosecution witnesses; 
  • Being present at all conferences with client and counsel. 

Lasry was also concerned about an increased workload should a barrister have to complete "administrative tasks". 

The following Monday saw Justice Terry Forrest in lock-step with Lasry, also awarding a temporary stay until an instructing solicitor could be guaranteed for the entire trial in a murder case. 

He thanked Lasry for compiling the list of solicitors' duties.

The rumour-mill at the Vic Supremes has it that the Chief Justice has been calling her peers in other jurisdictions to see if the justice system still works with only one defence lawyer. 

However, all this careful listing of the separate tasks of lowly solicitors seems a bit unnecessary - particularly in a jurisdiction that is technically fused, and where solicitors and barristers are supposedly interchangeable. 

According to practitioners on the ground in other fused states is not unusual for serious criminals cases to be conducted with only one lawyer each side. 

Ultimately, the courts have to get on with it. The accused cannot continue to languish while judges and the government squabble over legal aid funding. 

The problems with legal aid have been going on since Lex and Terry were in shorts.

In Lasry's own words:

"There have been debates about legal aid funding for many years. This is the latest of them." 

The profession is cheering the judiciary's brave stand to get more lawyers into court, even for cases that "could not be regarded as complex". 

It's unlikey that s.197 will save the day, because it is not as though these accused do not have legal representation. The court is saying they need more legal representation. 

There's an interesting chart here, showing how the Vic and NSW governments have been milking their respective public purpose funds to prop-up legal aid, while state (and Commonwealth) funding declines comparatively. 

Reporter: Alix Piatek

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.