SEARCH
Justinian News

Lehrmann v The Commonwealth and Corruption Concealment Commission ... Here's Brucie's Originating Application seeking legai aid funding for the investigation into "frivolous, 'James Bond' like allegations that the Applicant used 'official' information (being French submarine secrets) gathered on the night of 26 March 2019 for financial, professional and personal purposes, among other things ... More >> 

Politics Media Law Society

My Role in Gough's Downfall ... Reporter-at-Large … Scoops that flushed out the deceit behind the Dismissal … Big anniversary chinwag in Canberra on November 11 … The combined forces of Kerr, Ellicott and cousin Garfield … Constitutional manipulation … Maurice Byers to the rescue ... Read more >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Know one, purl one ... Iron Lady of legal rectitude endorses Gageler ... The chief justice wants judges on the straight and narrow ... The cardboard cutout model of legislative supremacy ... The evils of judicial activism ... Procrustes on the dance floor with the Legislative-Judicial Foxtrot ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


AI at work ... The Epstein Files ... What a resurrected Christopher Hitchens says about Trump and Epstein ... Video >> 

 

Justinian's Bloggers

Berlusconi's dream world ... Revenge politics in Italy ... Independence of prosecutors under attack ... Constitutional assault ... The years of lead ... Investigations reopened into old murders ... High drama at Milan's Leoncavallo ... Rome correspondent Silvana Olivetti reports ... Read more >> 

"If we’re only picking people who have got completely lily-white records then we’ll be missing out on a lot of people that can contribute to public life.

NSW Premier Chris Minns, endorsing Mal Lanyon, his pick for Police Commissioner, whose contributions to public life include shouting drunken obsenities at a paramedic who came to his aid, and commandeering a police launch for private entertainment on New Year's eve ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Schmoozing and betrayal ... Judge Water Softener rides into Integrityville mounted high on his horse ... Judicial review of corruption finding ... Intriguing submissions ... Unprecedented assistance to morals monitor ... The scale of the sub-rosa intrigue ... Plenty to think about ... Ginger Snatch reports ... Read more >> 

Justinian's archive

News Desk Special ... Angelic death notices from the bar ... Soapy slips on FOI changes ... Unusual interlocutory costs order for Chris Dale ... Judge ticks off Abbott in letters' page ... Knock About's festive salute to the coppers ... Read more >> 


 

 

« L.C. Gruzman, I. Temby & Teddy Kennedy | Main | Gruzman never too sick »
Saturday
Jan012000

Judge bounces lawyer tax scheme fight

From Justinian's hard copy era ... When tax schemes were in your face ... And Andrew Rogers ruled the NSW Supreme Court commercial division with an iron fist in a titanium glove 

From Justinian, July 1992

Justice Andrew Rogers seemed harsher than usual when confronted with a case brought by a finance company that lent money to a horse racing and breeding syndicate, largely comprising a bunch of solicitors.

But Rogers, Chief Judge of the NSW Supreme Court's Commercial Division, himself came in for some flak from Court of Appeal President, Justice M. Kirby.

In July last year the finance company, Mortgage Acceptance Nominees Ltd, MAN, lined up at the barrier in Rogers' court for a preliminary run-in with the syndicate.

But Rogers, with his hand firmly on the starter's button, asked what the issues were and added: "In its intrinsic nature it may be a commercial matter."

"There are three-and-a-half judges available to do the work of the commercial division and the construction list.

I see absolutely no reason why we should not devote ourselves to bona fide commercial transactions and leave you people, who are financiers of tax avoidance transactions, to sort yourselves out within the ordinary course.

Why should the court give what little time it has to completely unmeritorious litigants like your clients?"

MAN's counsel told the judge:

"We purchased horses and we leased them. We lent money. We took certain guarantees and certain other securities and we seek to enforce them."

Rogers: "You will, in the ordinary course of the court's business, but why should you get any preference whatsoever over paraplegics and widows and what have you?"

Counsel: "We are not asking, your honour... This is an action which your honour would ordinarily comprehend would be a commercial action."

Rogers: "I think I should remove it."

He ordered transfer of the three actions involved to the common law division.

In his reason for judgment Rogers said MAN, "saw fit, for its own business reason to make advances to persons who were indulging themselves in either tax postponement, tax reduction or tax avoidance."

"It is the absolute privilege of the plaintiff to do so. It is the absolute privilege of the defendants to borrow money for such purposes.

However, when it comes to competition between these who have entered into bona fide commercial transactions, which were in the ordinary course of business and which were not entered into simply for the purpose of fuelling tax reduction, then the persons and companies in the first category will always be accommodated by obtaining a hearing in this division of the court in preference to the second category of litigant."

 By a 2-1 majority Justices Mahony and Handley refused MAN's application for leave to the Court of Appeal.

However, in his dissenting judgment Kirby P said Rogers' decision would effectively delay determination of the actions by more than three years.

He would have granted leave, upheld the appeal and sent the matter back to Rogers to be dealt with according to law.

He said Rogers' power to transfer the proceedings "is controlled by law. It is not at large. It is not available to bend to the whim or idiosyncratic notions of the particular donee of the power".

"With very great respect to Rogers CJ Comm, whose experience and efficiency have contributed so greatly to the success of the commercial division, I do not believe that the imputed involvement of parties to a dispute, commercial in character, in tax minimisation provides a sound basis for distinguishing 'bona fide' from other commercial transactions.

It is commonplace that parties to commercial transactions will often seek to minimise the payment of income tax. To fail to do so may even amount to professional negligence on the part of the advisers of such parties."

 Kirby said making a decision on a transfer "does not provide an occasion for moral judgments."

Large sums were involved and the solicitor/borrowers were subject to the very high interest rate of 26 percent on any unpaid debt.

Listed as members of the horse racing and breeding syndicate were:

  • Rodney Graham Alexander
  • Russell John Clear
  • John Kenneth Connor
  • James Anthony Kennedy
  • Trevor Stanley Harding
  • Martin Arthur King
  • Nadaisan Raj Blessington
  • Bryce Norton
  • Larry Bartle
  • John Tomich
  • Ortica Holdings Pty Ltd
  • Sportpix Pty Ltd
  • Robert Gray Logan
  • Murray Raymond Bell
  • Peter James Tonkes

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.