Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Judicial shockers ... Latest from the trouble prone Queensland branch of the Federales ... Administrative law upsets ... Sandy Street overturned ... On the level in Canberra ... Missing aged care accountant ... Law shop managing director skewered ... Ginger Snatch reports from courtrooms around the nation ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


Smoke and mirrors ... Spiritual notes … Bishop fends off claim for damages from victim of priestly abuse … How does this work? … Victoria protects politician with DV offences … An oppressive no-publication regime … Celebrity judge battles antisemitism from the gala dinner circuit ... Read on ... 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

It's Hitlerish ... Reelection of a charlatan ... Republicans take popular vote for the first time in 20 years ... Amnesia ... Trashing a democracy ... Trump and his team of troubled men ... Mainstream media wilts in the eye of the storm ... Depravity, greed and revenge are the new normal ... Roger Fitch files from Washington ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Change of guard at the High Court ... Richard Glenn appointed CEO and Executive Director of the Court ... The same Richard Glenn who as Commonwealth Ombudsman was birched over mishandling a report into the legality of Robodebt ... More >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Shmagatha Shmistie 2.0 ... Another round with Vardy and Rooney ... Remote evidence from a witness - on the bus ... Brazilian magistrate looses his shirt ... CV qualifications propped up by pork pies ... Fast justice by Scissors & Paste ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt in London with the latest regrettable court-related conduct ... Read more >> 

"Today is about Dad's wishes and confirming all of our support for him and for his wishes. It shouldn't be difficult or controversial. Love you, Lachlan."   

Lachlan Murdoch's text message to his sister Elisabeth on the eve of a special meeting to discuss altering the family trust so that Lachlan would run and control News Corp and Fox News ... Quoted in the opinion of the Nevada Probate Commissioner who ruled against changing the terms of the trust ... The New York Times, December 9, 2024 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

The great interceptor ... Rugby League ... Dennis Tutty and the try he shouldn't have scored ... Case that changed the face of professional sport ... Growth of the player associations, courtesy of the Barwick High Court ... Free kick ... Restraint of trade ... Braham Dabscheck comments ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

Litigation's artful delays ... From Justinian's archive ... April 22, 2014 ... Lawyers and the complexity of litigation ... Delay as a defence tactic ... Access to justice includes preventing access to justice ... Reprising the Flower & Hart saga with starring role by Ian Callinan QC ... Abuse of process ... Queensland CJ declined to intervene ... Tulkinghorn on the case  ... Read more ... 


 

 

« When Soapy came to town | Main | Pass the parmesan »
Wednesday
Aug112010

Judicial complaints report packed with goodness

London Calling … A nation racked with choice and diversity awareness … Insensitive judicial officers sent to re-education camps … Australian election steadfastly ignored … Evelyn Waugh’s explanation for never voting … Leverhulme files

The young assistant in the packed KFC was thrown momentarily. I had displayed the temerity to request 2 pieces of chicken.

“Don’t you want the Colonel’s genuine real meal deal?”

“No thank you.”

“What about a free drink? We have lemonade, coke, coffee or water? Still? Or sparkling?”

“No thank you!”

He was no longer looking at me.

“Do you want the traditional recipe or the Mexican Chilli option?”

“No.”

I was only listening vaguely by now and mumbling, “Two pieces of chicken, please.”

The queue was building.

“Do you want any sauce with that? We have Mustard Burn Out, Tickly Tomato or Tasteless Vegan.”

It was too much. I burst loudly and badly into song with a hit by The Hoosiers, which has been on the wireless a lot lately.

“Stop giving me choices. Stop giving me choices.”

* * *

But menu options, as they are now called, dominate our lives and come in all forms.

I had a phone call from the bank the other day. The caller asked for me by name.

“Speaking,” I replied.

There then came the mantra which sends me into orbit.

“Now I should tell you that this call is being recorded for training purposes.”

“Whose training?” I asked.

“I beg your pardon,” he said. “Can I just verify that I am speaking to the right person?”

“This is my phone number and you called me,” I said. “What do you want?”

“I'm not allowed to talk to you unless I can confirm your identity. But if you do not wish to tell me who you are for security reasons, you do have other options…”

“Write to me, please,” I said and put the phone down ever so nicely.

It is not much better on line. You have to endure an obstacle course to book a flight or to find how much you owe on your phone bill.

The password palaver (we are told to have different ones and I can never remember any of them) then leads to the feedback farce as your tormentors ask you to fill out a form which tells them how they handled your question or better still, your complaint.

But it keeps people in jobs, I suppose.

* * *

This brings me neatly to the terribly informative website of the Office of Judicial Complaints.

Its annual report is hot off the PDF and, as usual, diversity awareness is a compelling theme.

The communiqué is packed full of key performance indicators and drivers and there are proactive manual logs by dedicated caseworkers who seek to embed a welcome sea-change in lateral thinking.

And there is this cracking photo that shows the whiteness of the commissioner.

Work to be done there, I suspect.

It is striking that many more pages are devoted to the performance of the office, and how it could do better, than are spent on naughty and errant judges.

Of the complaints, the overwhelming majority came from litigants in person and the vast majority of those were from bloody palefaces.

Twenty-eight beaks were removed from office last year of which 25 were magistrates.

The most heinous offence was committed by the JP who said to a differently-raced individual:

“We take exception to people coming to our shores and abusing our hospitality.”

If he’d said that in Australia, they would now be calling him Senator-elect.

Mr Recorder Crawford: scene at BBQ led to resignationThe bench-holder was lucky not to have been sacked, but he was punished cruelly by being sent for training and removed from the mentoring list.

A couple of years ago, a Mr Recorder Crawford got into strife for harassing his estranged missus and her new beau, Mr Buttimore, at a barby.

In the midst of disciplinary proceedings against him Crawfo wisely resigned.

The Lord Chancellor and the Lord Chief Justice acknowledged his past judicial performance and his “outstanding contribution to diversity issues in the legal world and beyond”.

Is there anything beyond the legal world?

* * *

In other distressing British news, queuing is on the wane and a Leeds Council is in some bother for sending a questionnaire to householders to ask about their health, race, religious beliefs and the gender of the person with whom they prefer to tremble knees.

The council managers say they are hoping to find out their customer’s needs.

They aspire nobly to give a fair and equal service to all and questions about hernias and hosannas will help.

Meanwhile, the data is being sent to building maintenance firms, alarm fitters and drain cleaners.

Each a worthy stakeholder.

* * *

The Australian election has rated nary a mention over here and the gist of the confusing coverage is that Julia (Snoz) Gillard is winning one day and losing the next.

Many English people are amazed when I tell them voting is compulsory in Australia.

Some think it admirable that people take responsibility for those they elect, but I tell them that the system’s major drawback is that the idiots get a say and that it causes the politicians to pander to greed and prejudice.

Waugh: refused to voteEvelyn Waugh (A Little Order, Penguin Books) never voted in a parliamentary election.

To Waugh all authority emanated from the Crown.

“Judges, Anglican bishops, soldiers, sailors, ambassadors, the Poet Laureate, the postman and especially Ministers exist by the royal will.

“In the past three hundred years,” he wrote, “the Crown has adopted what seems to me a very hazardous process of choosing advisers: popular election.

“I do not aspire to advise my Sovereign in her choice of servants.”

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.