Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Unread emails ... Family law barrister in Adelaide neglects to attend to emails ... Reminders to renew her ticket studiously ignored ... Unravelling chaos ... Trials invalidated ... Liability of Law Society and Conduct Commissioner ... Breach of statutory requirement ... Damages ... From our Team on the Torrens ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


An Australian Abroad ... An essay with pictures … Egypt and the Grand Museum … No end to the antiquities … Down the Nile on a dahabiya … Tombs and temples … Paris and industrial-scale tourism … The Yarts & Kulture ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Annihilation of the now ...Trump's campaign of destruction ... Fake emergencies ... Pointless and farcical executive orders ... Gangsterism ... Looting ... Corruption ... Shakedowns ... White rage ... Christian nationalism ... Roger Fitch unloads ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


 

South Australian lawyer practising without a ticket ... Latest developments in Law Society of SA v Betro ... As an alternative to invalidating all the family law trials involving the unlicenced barrister, the Full Court has been approached re possibility of granting a retrospective practising certificate ... The mother in relevant proceedings applied to be joined to argue against this ... Joinder granted on a limited basis to make written submissions. See also Unread emails 

Justinian's Bloggers

Letter from London ... Weather report ... Starmer sinking ... Farage rising ... Fake law firm ... Fake cases ...  NHS employee cleans up with woke case for hurt feelings ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt files from Blighty ... Read more >> 

"In its self-image, Australia has changed from a nation of tough, resilient Anzacs to a snowflake society of victims. This can be seen in the rise of identity politics, cancel culture, trigger warnings, unconscious bias, workplace Broderickism, LGBTQIA+ pleading, colonisation impacts, hidden disabilities and welfare dependency. Hurt feelings, offensive words, micro-aggressions, workload stress and anxiety now form the basis of workers compensation claims."

Mark Latham MLC - a dissenting statement in a parliamentary report on proposed changes to workers compensation law ... May 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Zeilgeist litigation ... Matt Collins KC on live-streaming of high-profile trials ... Social media nightmare ... Abuse of barristers ... Chilling emails ... Trials as a form of public entertainment ... Courts sleepwalking into a dangerous zone ... Framework needed to balance competing interests ... Paper delivered to Australian Lawyers Alliance Conference ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Justice Jeff Shaw's bingle ... Supreme Court judge's drink-drive experience ... Cars damaged in narrow Sydney street ... Touch driving ... Missing blood sample ... Equality before the law may not apply to judges ... Judges behind the wheel ... From Justinian's Archive ... November 4, 2004 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Top End turmoil | Main | Costs snafu tangles chambers »
Tuesday
May202014

Right royal skewering of NSW republicans 

Victorian silken-one warns about the evils of NSW SCs ... Where is the public interest? ... NSW should adopt the Victorian silk selection model ... The inferiority of Senior Counsel ... Discuss among yourselves 

Victorian Queen's Counsel getting ready for court

FROM deep down in chambers within the Royal Yarraside Bar-Bar comes a secret, internal report putting the needle into the rum soaked corps of rebels in NSW who have opted to reject the plumage of Queen's Counsel. 

The eight page missive whizzing around William Street and its purlieus is titled Issues Paper on the Public Interest and the Office of Queens Counsel

The authorship is mysterious, saying only that it is "generated by a member of the Victorian Bar for discussion within chambers". 

It's good to see a document that has been "generated", rather than authored - but never let it be said that Vic's Queens would pass-up an opportunity to put the mockers on the Emerald City's uniquely rugged Senior Counsel selection machine. 

The secret report hoes into the idea that the appointment of Queen's Counsel is against the public interest. Of course QCs are in the public interest, because they are in the interest of barristers. 

Great agricultural blows are directed at the Priestley report into whether NSW should readopt QCs.

When it came to Asian jurisdictions, apparently the Priestley Seven failed to "draw a distinction between fused practice jurisdictions and those with independent bars". 

Hong Kong is regarded as having the only independent bar in the region. 

This oversight is described as "appalling [and] calls into doubt the rationality of the majority finding [of the Priestley Seven]".  

"On this point alone the majority view should be consigned to oblivion for failing to uphold the traditions and importance of independence and the Bar. It is better seen to be a political diatribe of supporting the NSW Bar appointment system without analysing where this system fits within the importance of an independent Bar." 

What the NSW Bar should be doing, according to the voice from Yarraside, is to adopt the Victorian system, whereby silks are handwoven by the CJ. 

In this way the prospect of political meddling with the sacred list is avoided. 

The paper claims that the CJ's involvement makes the process "independent", whereas in NSW the selection of SCs is done by the Bar Association in the name of the president, and so cannot be "independent". 

"Perhaps with NSW Bar continuing with appointments made by their Association only that that lack of impartiality in appointment does not really permit the appointments to be considered as being the same as those States involving the Chief Justice leading to the appointment of Queen's Counsel [sic]." 

This rather ignores the reality that Vic's silks are appointed by the CJ, but the due diligence grunt work and bottom sniffing is done by a committee of nine, of which six positions are held by bar boys from Dixieland Chambers. 

See Victorian selection method here   

In NSW, CJ Bathurst keeps a black ball in his pocket, and he can veto anyone he thinks shouldn't be on the bar prez's list. He doesn't need a committee, so top that for "independence". 

The poor Priestley people get a frightful pounding by the anonymous brief scribbling his missive beside Victoria's version of the great, grey-green, greasy Limpopo. 

For instance, for the NSW "No" case to assert that the public interest is best served by the present NSW system is ... 

"nothing more than a self- serving statement. It is strongly suggested here that the NSW system is flawed and deeply so. It strangely proceeds upon the basis that there would be political interference open in the future – it does not address the Victorian system nor the recommendations of the minority on the report."

He then turns-up the Kenwood Mixmaster to speed 10: 

"There is now a strong argument that because the NSW Bar appointment system is so different to that of Victoria and Queensland, both of which rely solely upon an independent Chief Justice to make the appointments of silks, that there should be a different designation of NSW counsel as SCs so as to not confuse consumers with QCs who are appointed after a truly independent appointment process." 

[snip] 

Until such time as the NSW Bar has an independent system for the appointment of silk which would entitle those members as recognition as QCs they are correct in maintaining the system of SCs. They are not the same as QCs.

[snip] 

NSW should be encouraged to abandon its system and follow the example of Victoria as soon as possible." 


See, Issues paper on the public interest and the office of Queen's Counsel 

See, Report of the Priestley Seven  

See, NSW Bar announcement on retaining the current system of SCs 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.