Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Potty Mouth Solicitor Dispatched ... NSW Court of Appeal takes dim view of solicitor who laced his correspondence with disrespectful insults ... Insufficiently professional ... Arrived from Greece with only his underpants ... No contrition ... Anthony Kanaan files ... Read more >>

Politics Media Law Society


The End Of The Affair ... Lord Moloch’s bid for more Fox News fans … The Wall Street Journal rallies the MAGA base …Will the old rogue abandon his journalists? … Is “bawdy” the right word here? … The Deep State plumbs the depths … John and Stanley Roth’s generosity to loving causes ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Suing for defamation - it's such a good idea ...Federal Court of Australia ... Sydney barrister loses bid for extension of time to bring appeal over decision allowing Giles George to intervene to seek an equitable lien over costs ... Falling out between barrister and firm after successful defamation action ... No error or procedural unfairness ... From Stephen Murray at the Gazette of Law & Journalism ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Major victory for the media as public interest defence established in large and lengthy defamation case brought by orthopaedic surgeon ... Al Muderis v Nine Network, Fairfax and The Age ... Good journalism wins the day ... More >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Postcard from London ... Summertime - And the living' is easy ... Votes for 16-year olds ... Paralegal's theft by pen ... Spy helping British intelligence from his job at Border Force ... Super-injunction comes out of the shadows ... Feed them strawberries and cream ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt files from Blighty ... Read more >> 

"I've stopped six wars in the last - I'm averaging about a war a month. But the last three were very close together. India and Pakistan, and a lot of them. Congo was just and Rwanda was just done, but you probably know I won't go into it very much, because I don't know the final numbers yet. I don't know. Numerous people were killed, and I was dealing with two countries that we get along with very well, very different countries from certain standpoints. They've been fighting for 500 years, intermittently, and we solved that war. You probably saw it just came out over the wire, so we solved it ..."

President Donald Trump at a meeting in Scotland with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer ... July 28, 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Home Duties ... The dumping of Attorney General Mark Dreyfus ... Behind the scenes ... Bastardry among the brothers ... Unfinished business ... Family law, privacy ... Considerable policy and legislative results ... Here's Michelle Rowland as AG ... What are her priors? ... Polly Peck reports from the Gallery ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Abolish silks ... Sydney SC writes to the editor calling for abolition of the silk system ... Appointments are anachronistic ... It's not a matter of ability, only notability ... Secret blackballing ... "Corrupt" process ... Confessions from an insider who played the game ... From Justinian's Archive, October 24, 2002 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Temby and police indemnities | Main
Saturday
Jan012000

The Botany Boys

The Botany Council bribery case ... ICAC less fun in Ian Temby's day ... Earlier Labor scandals in NSW ... Rezoning of Murdoch land  ... Memories far from faded ... From Justinian's archive, February 1990

Temby at ICAC: not keen on chasing the Botany bribery case

IAN Temby’s reasons for not taking the Laurie Brereton bribery matters further are instructive, particularly because this case is one of the greatest unresolved public scandals of the NSW Labor Party. 

At the time Brereton was the local member, a party fixer, and later a Wran government minister. 

He is alleged to have offered election funding to four Labor aldermen on the Botany Council if they opposed a move to rezone land owned by News Ltd from industrial to residential. 

If they did not oppose the proposed rezoning of Roop's land, they would lose their preselections. 

The ICAC report gives two main reasons for not pushing on with finding out whether Brereton was a crook or not.

First, on the basis of decisions such as Herron v McGregor, Whitbread v Cook, Watson v Attorney General and Cook v Purcell, proceedings against Brereton could not be taken.

These cases say that a prosecution can be stayed as an abuse of process if brought after long and unexplained delay.

“It is too late to rectify the situation now. It would be quite wrong to proceed further against him,” says Temby’s report.

Secondly, ICAC itself was not keen to pursue the matter.

“The prospects of the commission now discovering the truth - whether as to the original alleged corrupt conduct, or subsequent events - are quite remote.

With the passage of time memories do fade; sometimes they are converted to a more convenient or less embarrassing position than accords with historical facts.

The purpose of investigation is to ascertain the truth. That cannot now be done, and it must be doubted whether any very useful purpose would be served by making the attempt.”

Well, a couple of points about that.

1. The "useful purpose" is that if an investigation were to discover that Brereton had attempted to bribe Botany Council aldermen then it would be inappropriate for him to be a member of any parliament. That in itself would be a useful purpose.

2. Some memories are far from faded and are still convinced of the truth. 

Temby did not discuss the extent of faded memories with former Labor alderman Jim Slattery and Owen Davis - both of whom are crystal clear on the matter.

They still clearly remember being summonsed to Brereton’s house where they say the bribe was offered to secure their vote to stop the the rezoning, which would adversely affect News Ltd's land in the municipality.

Jim Slattery was kind enough to call up to my office the other day. He told me that ICAC had not discussed the state of his memory with him and as far as he’s concerned his recollection of those events is good.

Owen Davis is in retirement up near Wyong and said he will “never forget” what happened.

He wrote to the Premier’s Department about the matter some time ago and his enquiry was passed on to ICAC.

He received a letter back for ICAC, which he described as “one of the most shithouse letters I have ever read”.

“I told them, ‘if you want information just look at Hansard’ ... The whole thing is one of the greatest injustices,” Mr Davis told your correspondent.

Henry Morris is President of South Sydney Junior Rugby League Club and he says he wasn’t approached by anyone from Temby’s team to test whether his memory had faded.

N.B. the alleged bribe to vote the “right way” was $5,000 for each alderman. This was followed by threats of loss of preselection, threats which in due course were carried out.

See also Can of Worms

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.