Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Judicial shockers ... Latest from the trouble prone Queensland branch of the Federales ... Administrative law upsets ... Sandy Street overturned ... On the level in Canberra ... Missing aged care accountant ... Law shop managing director skewered ... Ginger Snatch reports from courtrooms around the nation ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


Smoke and mirrors ... Spiritual notes … Bishop fends off claim for damages from victim of priestly abuse … How does this work? … Victoria protects politician with DV offences … An oppressive no-publication regime … Celebrity judge battles antisemitism from the gala dinner circuit ... Read on ... 

This area does not yet contain any content.
Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

It's Hitlerish ... Reelection of a charlatan ... Republicans take popular vote for the first time in 20 years ... Amnesia ... Trashing a democracy ... Trump and his team of troubled men ... Mainstream media wilts in the eye of the storm ... Depravity, greed and revenge are the new normal ... Roger Fitch files from Washington ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Change of guard at the High Court ... Richard Glenn appointed CEO and Executive Director of the Court ... The same Richard Glenn who as Commonwealth Ombudsman was birched over mishandling a report into the legality of Robodebt ... More >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Shmagatha Shmistie 2.0 ... Another round with Vardy and Rooney ... Remote evidence from a witness - on the bus ... Brazilian magistrate looses his shirt ... CV qualifications propped up by pork pies ... Fast justice by Scissors & Paste ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt in London with the latest regrettable court-related conduct ... Read more >> 

"Today is about Dad's wishes and confirming all of our support for him and for his wishes. It shouldn't be difficult or controversial. Love you, Lachlan."   

Lachlan Murdoch's text message to his sister Elisabeth on the eve of a special meeting to discuss altering the family trust so that Lachlan would run and control News Corp and Fox News ... Quoted in the opinion of the Nevada Probate Commissioner who ruled against changing the terms of the trust ... The New York Times, December 9, 2024 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

The great interceptor ... Rugby League ... Dennis Tutty and the try he shouldn't have scored ... Case that changed the face of professional sport ... Growth of the player associations, courtesy of the Barwick High Court ... Free kick ... Restraint of trade ... Braham Dabscheck comments ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

Litigation's artful delays ... From Justinian's archive ... April 22, 2014 ... Lawyers and the complexity of litigation ... Delay as a defence tactic ... Access to justice includes preventing access to justice ... Reprising the Flower & Hart saga with starring role by Ian Callinan QC ... Abuse of process ... Queensland CJ declined to intervene ... Tulkinghorn on the case  ... Read more ... 


 

 

« A place in the community | Main | Shakespeare on refugees »
Wednesday
May182016

That's not funny

Appearing before the gods of the bench ... Dire warning about flippancy in court ... Correctly reading the judicial temperament ... Traps for young players ... Junior Junior on adjournment techniques 

BARRISTERS love to give advice to junior juniors. 

This is obviously a good thing; a full account of my legal knowledge and experience could be written on the back of an envelope.

One piece of advice I received early on has stuck with me. I was told: don't be flippant.

Flippant remarks, sarcastic banter, and other attempts to draw laughs from the cheap seats are not to be made in court. Court is a sacrosanct place where one must treat the judge like a god.

Of course, not all judges are the same.

Some are the Old Testament God, angry and difficult to appease. Barristers are habitually turned to pillars of salt, leading to gnashing of teeth and emptying of the chambers' drinks fridge.

Others are the New Testament God. A nose for justice, but fail to follow this judge's lead and your client could face eternal damnation. 

A few judges are Dionysus, the Greek god of wine. They appear to be listening to you, but are actually day-dreaming about golf and boutique pinot noir. Try to keep your submissions short.

There is at least one Jupiter, king of the Roman gods. He fights your case, fights your opponent's case, then writes a judgment that downs you both.

Finally, some judges are atheists. They do not believe in a higher authority, and scoff when you suggest that they are bound by one. Chaos and panic ordinarily ensues.

Whatever god one is appearing before, I am fast learning that care must be taken not to overstep the mark. Of course, for every rule there are exceptions. One such occurred recently before the New Testament God, ruler of the living and the dead, who was presiding over His holy list on Hospital Road.

It was a particularly busy list, and one hapless sole (we shall call him Job) had clearly been thrown under the proverbial bus by a colleague. Job had only held the brief for a matter of minutes before being shuttled off to face judgment. Presumably, the instructions he'd been given were to the effect of, "It's a simple matter, you shouldn't have any problems, just get it adjourned". 

Any junior junior that hears those words immediately thinks of Admiral Ackbar's immortal phrase: It's a trap!

After some minutes of judicial battering, the judge informed young Job of Ill Fortune in no uncertain terms of his great displeasure. 

"This is wholly unsatisfactory. You don't appear to have any knowledge of the history of this matter, or indeed have any idea what this case is about. Perhaps the barrister with carriage should appear in person next time."

Job avoided a grimace, and instead cracked a smile.

"Your Honour, this is what is colloquially referred to as a 'Hospital Road pass'."

Those in the gallery waited for Job to be turned into a pillar of salt, but His Holiness instead laughed. "You should have opened with that. I would have given you the adjournment."

Oh ye, of little faith. Here endeth the lesson.

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Member Account Required
You must have a member account on this website in order to post comments. Log in to your account to enable posting.