Search Archive
Free Newsletter sign-up
Search Justinian
Justinian's news stories

The "sleek kangaroo" of Bangalow ... He thought it was romance ... She believed it was sexual harassment ... Sal Vasta gets to work on law firm principal's over-wrought advances ... $170,000 awarded to female solicitor trapped at Bangelow law shop with predatory pest ... Read more ... 


Justinian Columnists

Ming the Merciless ... Menzies: The Art of Politics ... Placing material success at the centre of things ... Vision of a bigger future goes missing ... Egon Kisch, H.V. Evatt, Petrov ... Politics of Australia and the sad state of now ... Procrustes ferments ... Read more ... 


 

 

This form does not yet contain any fields.

    "Sydney is such a strange place. The only place in the world where they have so many parks. Everywhere, national parks. They are only good for snakes." 

    Harry Triguboff, the boss of Meriton, builder of cheap and ugly apartment buildings, complaining that parks are an impediment to property developers. The Wentworth Courier, May 29, 2019 ... Read more flatulence ... 


    Justinian Featurettes

    Love of the French ... Distress that Australia's great wine commentator and educator celebrated his birthday with a selection of French wines ... What's wrong with local wines for a well-deserved celebratory toast? ... Gabriel Wendler stirs up a storm in a wine glass ... Read more ... 


    Justinian's archive

    When only the victim speaks the truth ... Author Bri Lee's book Eggshell Skull scoops up another prize - this time at the Australian Book Industry Awards ... A story of childhood sexual assault ... While the book continues to collect awards, the author's view about how natural justice ought to work should be read with caution ... In 2018 we published lawyer Joanna Jenkins's review ... It's timely to reprise her concerns about the book ... Read more ... 


     

     

    « Protection racket | Main | Winners re-elected »
    Sunday
    Nov112012

    Advice from the lower deck

    Combative words ... Canberra beak objects to florid phrases from Dyson Heydon ... Debasing respect for the judicial process ... Lessons in language 

    David Mossop: writing style is crucial

    THERE's nothing quite so enjoyable as a good judicial ticking-off - particularly when the lower end of the food chain is snipping at the upper end. 

    Here we have the star of stare decisis, ACT magistrate David (Moose) Mossop, a household name in legal circles, giving that non-entity Dyson Heydon a good birching in the latest issue of the judges' bible, the ACT Bar Bulletin. 

    Davo went to town on some of Dyce's arch remarks in the tobacco plain packaging decision, where the antipodean representative of the Duke of Marlborough was in a lonely minority. 

    Readers will be familiar with parts of his judgment, because they are recited at breakfast tables throughout Lawyer Land: 

    "These are just minor examples of a common characteristic of s 51(xxxi) litigation - that the Commonwealth repeats arguments it has advanced in earlier cases over many years, despite their failure, and often their repeated failure.

    After a 'great' constitutional case, the tumult and the shouting dies. The captains and the kings depart. Or at least the captains do; the Queen in Parliament remains forever. Solicitors General go. New Solicitors General come. This world is transitory. But some things never change. The flame of the Commonwealth's hatred for that beneficial constitutional guarantee, s.51(xxxi), may flicker, but it will not die. That is why it is eternally important to ensure that that flame does not start a destructive blaze." 

    Dyse should have been more careful and avoided upsetting Magistrate Mossop, who felt that this sort of language tends "to debase and lessen the respect for the judicial process". 

    I'm told that throughout the wide, brown land, citizens' respect for judges and the law plunged following the front-page treatment given to Heydon J's remarks in JT International SA v Commonwealth of Australia

    Moose continued: 

    "In my view it is undesirable for a judge, particularly a judge of the High Court, to embark on any such extravagant criticism  of the party. 

    It may be that the party continues to advance arguments which have been previously rejected … However, that of itself does not warrant the kind of criticism in the tobacco case."

    [snip] 

    "The position of dissenters is not improved by the extravagance of language. Just as overstatement is poor advocacy so too is it a poor judgment writing style." 

    Not all of the High Court judge's writings were beyond the Pale. 

    His famous line in Aon Risk Services v ANU apparently is emblazoned on t-shirts, and is reflective of HH's "biting, dry humour": 

    "The torpid languor of one hand washes the drowsy procrastination of the other."  

    However, Davo thought most people would most likely be spared the distress of Heydon's style because in cases where there is a clear majority it is likely that "harassed practitioners" would be too busy locating the ratio decidendi of the majority judgments. 

    Madge Mossop is no stranger to the High Court, having been Michael McHugh's associate in the 1990s. So he knows what he's talking about.

    Dyse better drop the gilded flourishes ... or else. 

    See: November 2012 ACT Bar Bulletin

    Reader Comments

    There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
    Editor Permission Required
    You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.