Search Justinian
Justinian's news stories

An afterlife for political flops ... The AAT has been trashed and stacked with the flotsam of the Liberal Party ... Cronyism ... Peter Dutton's "Australian values" ... The defenestration of the administrative review functions of the Commonwealth ... Read more ... 


Justinian Columnists

Hale Spiderwoman ... 11 out of 11 ... UK Supremes on a null and void prorogation ... Judicial review of the prerogative power of the crown ... Principle of parliamentary sovereignty ... Her Maj the cypher ... Welcome back Sir Edward Coke ... Procrustes explains ... Read more ... 


Justinian's Tweets


 

 

Justinian's Bloggers

Transcript of the week ... A solicitor appears before a Yarraside judicial registrar ... Where's my stay? ... Waiver of court fees ... What's going on? ... It's so simple ... Give me a case ... Seeking to appeal against an order that is not a final order ... No arguable case ... The next case has been called ... Read more ... 

This form does not yet contain any fields.

    "One of the reasons I'm enthusiastic about Boris Johnson's prime ministership is because if there was ever a cometh-the-hour, cometh-the-man moment in the recent history of this country, this is it and he is that person."    

    George Brandis, Australia's High Commissioner to the UK, speaking in Manchester at the Policy Exchange. October 2, 2019 ... Read more flatulence ... 


    Justinian Featurettes

    Drugs, money and death ... The brutality of the drug business in Columbia ... Birds of Passage ... America, the greedy satan ... Complex codes of honour ... Peace and war ... Miss Lumière reviews the spectacle ... Read more ... 


    Justinian's archive

    Is there something amusing, Mr Foreman? ... Defamatorium ... Outburst from barrister … Solicitor suing Financial Review ... Juror looked chastened after being directly addressed by counsel during summing-up … How to handle an outburst from the bar table... Let the transcript do the talking ... From Justinian's archive, March 2012 ... Read more ... 


     

     

    « A free press finds a fierce advocate | Main | Julian Morrow »
    Tuesday
    Nov062018

    Law of the tribe

    Former USyd law dean champions Indigenous law degree in Canada ... Juris indigenarum doctor ... Building trust over time ... Australian law schools yet to embrace the opportunity ... Asking tough questions about Indigenous legal orders ... Corporate support ... Nick Bonyhady talks with Jeremy Webber  

    Killcare: where Canadian Indigenous law degree was hatched

    Killcare Beach on the Central Coast of NSW is a long way from the University of Victoria in British Columbia. 

    In 2004, John Borrows and Jeremy Webber from the UVic Law School were at Killcare when Borrows raised the idea of a joint degree in indigenous and Canadian law.

    Now 14 years after conception, 25 students a year will study units like Canadian common law in intense comparison with a particular Canadian indigenous tradition. Webber told Justinian

    "My colleague Val Napoleon is teaching property law. She's teaching it in comparison with Gitksan law, a people just inland from the coast of Northern British Columbia. Another colleague, David Milward is Cree from Saskatchewan, he's teaching criminal law, dealing with the way in which disruptive and antisocial conduct is dealt with in Cree law."

    The students, who will spend one year longer at UVic than their counterparts in the pure common law stream, will emerge both with a juris doctor and a juris indigenarum doctor.

    It will be taught in English, but incorporate a unit on the language and law of the Coast Salish peoples - giving students an understanding of how the two inform each other.

    It is fundamentally different to the approach taken by Australian universities, including the University of Sydney where Webber was dean from 1998 to 2002. 

    At an undergraduate level, Sydney University has one unit explicitly focussed on indigenous people and the law. That unit focusses primarily on how indigenous people interact with whitefella law - not on indigenous legal orders.

    Webber explains that in Canada too, law schools have typically provided the "merest introduction to the fact that there are indigenous legal traditions". 

    Webber: tools to interpret and develop indigenous law For Indigenous students Webber says that in many ways, it has been "an education in displacement" because students don't gain any skills in navigating their own legal traditions. 

    This has consequences. He says:

    "Certainly non-indigenous law doesn't have much currency in indigenous contexts ... or at least it's very much seen as being imposed externally. And frankly it doesn't do good work as law in many contexts."

    Though there are important and notable exceptions, he says that when indigenous groups go to Canadian lawyers for help with governance documents ... 

    "... frankly what they get from us is not all that different from a model that has been developed in a non-indigenous context, striking out the name of regional municipality and writing in the name of the indigenous community." 

    The same is often true here.

    But the purpose of the new degree is not to uncritically reify indigenous legal traditions.

    Webber emphasises that a background of trust has allowed scholars and students at UVic to ask tough questions of Indigenous legal orders, including questions of gender relations and sexual orientation.

    It is important that such questions be asked because the university sees the degree as equipping students with tools to interpret and further develop indigenous law.

    "They're ... traditions that live in people attempting to interpret them, attempting to apply them, attempting to figure out how to have a child welfare system that works in communities."

    The trust that has allowed the University of Victoria to launch this degree has been long earned.

    For over 20 years, about a third of UVic first year law students have spent several days in indigenous communities.

    Webber says it's often their "first experience speaking to an indigenous person, let alone living in a community". 

    The law school also has a significant indigenous research unit, a large indigenous alumni base and student body - about nine percent of the current general law cohort.

    It will hire more indigenous academics to teach the program and pay indigenous community educators for the time they spend with UVic students when they travel to communities as part of their studies for the new degree.

    Two of Webber's respected Indigenous colleagues in the law faculty, Borrows and Van Napoleon, were central to the conception and development of the curriculum. Webber says: "It would have been utterly unattainable without them." 

    Australian law schools are a long way from launching a program such as this, but the Canadian experience shows the value of building a good faith relationship over time. 

    Contrary to what one might expect here, Webber says the project did not become politicised. 

    "It was quite common that the people who worked in industry with the indigenous people themselves saw the value of this." 

    He adds:

    "As the question of support ... climbed up the ladder, I sometimes wondered whether scepticism also seemed to build." 

    Webber suspects that the project's "transformative aspiration was worrying to some actors who when it came right down to it were quite comfortable ... with the relationship" as it stood.

    Nonetheless, the program ultimately achieved a broad base of support. It is being funded through large private donations from an array of foundations - some tied to major companies - and deep public support from the province of British Columbia.

    For large scale funding of indigenous education to be a fairly uncontroversial public good is itself a major step. 

    Reader Comments

    There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
    Editor Permission Required
    You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.