Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Bennett birched by WA Bureau de Spank ... Perth big shot ... Professional misconduct ... Disclosure of privileged information ... Guardianship proceedings ... Breach of orders ... Conscious disregard of the law ... Consideration of recklessness ... Breach of Harman obligation ... Anthony Kanaan reports ... Read more ...

Politics Media Law Society


Back in the ring ... Rape on the minister’s couch … Cover-up … Of course, there was a cover-up … Bettina Arndt and the Institute for the Presumption of Bruce Lehrmann’s Innocence … Linda Reynolds needs sympathy and money … Justice Lee’s loose crumbs ... Read on ... 

This area does not yet contain any content.
Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Other Voices, Other Rooms ... Hack attack on barrister ... Heavy-handed Jewish lobby calling the shots ... No support from chambers ... Eerie silence from professional bodies about Gaza atrocities ... Latest cancellations ... Free speech in a spin ... From our Editorial Board ... Read more ... 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


All you need to know about homicide in Australia ... Latest report from the Australian Institute of Criminology ... More >> 

Justinian's Bloggers

Celebrations at the Lubyanka ... NSW Supreme Court judges gear up for a big birthday party ... Planned revelries ... Serious reflections ... History by the yards ... Monumental book ... Artworks ... Musicale ... From Miss Ginger Snatch, an associate of judges ... Read more ... 

"Throughout every step of this process, I have been surrounded by the love of my wonderful family, as well as incredibly supportive friends and colleagues. I can never thank them enough. I also want to say how grateful I am to all the generous members of the public who have approached me almost every single day to express, often through tears, their unwavering support."

Celebrity TV presenter and defamation defendant Lisa Wilkinson outside the court after Justice Lee's verdict in the Lehrmann case ... Aoril 15, 2024 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Algorithmic injustices ... Criminal justice in the data age ... The lurking dangers when algorithms are used to dispense justice ... Predicting the pattern of potential offenders ... Anthony Kanaan interviews Dr Tatiana Dancy, author of Artificial Justice ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

Justice Jeff Shaw's bingle ... Supreme Court judge's drink-drive experience ... Cars damaged in narrow Sydney street ... Touch driving ... Missing blood sample ... Equality before the law may not apply to judges ... Judges behind the wheel ... From Justinian's Archive ... November 4, 2004 ... Read more ... 


 

 

« RBG reincarnated | Main | The Courier »
Friday
Apr302021

The United States vs Billie Holiday

The FBI's obsession with Strange Fruit ... Music from the devil ... War Against Drugs ... Reluctance to give up lynching ... Un-American activities ... All that jazz ... Hoover on the case ... Miss Lumière at the cinema

Holiday: hounded by Hoover

As if we didn't already know: J. Edgar Hoover has a lot to answer for, including hounding one of the greatest of all jazz singers to her untimely death, aged 44.

The United States vs Billie Holiday is a timely, if confused reminder of America's crude racist underpinning, in this instance successfully prosecuted by agents of the bug-eyed, cross-dressing, mother-lovin' FBI chief.

The film is based on Johann Hari's book, Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs, which examined the role of real-life FBI agents Harry J. Anslinger and new black recruit Jimmy Fletcher (a hunky Trevante Rhodes) in bringing down Billie Holiday.

What a fall. Although, as we learn, Billie all but crawled her way out of the gutter (a Harlem brothel) on the husky chords of her stunning vocal talent.

Along the way, she picked up some bad men and some equally bad habits - booze, heroin and the blues.

In particular, the FBI wants Billie to stop singing Strange Fruit, Time Magazine's "song of the century" because it describes (rather lyrically it must be said) lynching, a practice the film informs us was still not banned in 2020.

In 1947 when the main action begins, lynching is very much in vogue in the south, and Anslinger (Garrett Hedund) wants to keep it that way - "jazz is the devil's music" - by getting Billie arrested as part of the US government's "war against drugs". 

She's a soft target and spends a year in prison before returning "clean" to a sell-out concert in front of a mixed-race audience at Carnegie Hall.

Hoover and his henchmen are ever more driven to root out such "un-American" activity. 

Director Lee Daniels (Monster's Ball, Precious) has rich historical material to mine, but seems uncertain whether he's making a biopic, a docu-drama, a political thriller or a love story.

A hokey script by Susan Lori-Parks doesn't help, nor does the schmaltzy musical score (Billie's incandescent songs aside).

Stylistically and structurally The United States vs Billie Holiday is a chien's breakfast (we even see a few of those involving Billie's own pampered pooches) albeit one not quite saved by a thrilling central performance.

Singer-songwriter Andra Day as Billie is a force to be reckoned with, chewing up the celluloid with her reckless intensity and physicality. 

It's no surprise Day was nominated for best actress in a leading role across the awards spectrum. She missed out on the Academy Award, but won a Golden Globe. 

As Billie, she's a bona fide firecracker, both raw and vulnerable, burning life at both ends, injecting heroin in the middle and making all the wrong decsions.

"I sing what de fuck I want," she spits at her sleazy manager, whom she later, unwisely marries. 

There's subterfuge (Jimmy goes undercover to get her arrested), love, violence, sex and drugs (sometimes simultaneously) and sheer nastiness (the FBI arresting and handcuffing her for heroin possession on her hospital deathbed) aplenty.

But that's not what makes The United States vs Billie Holiday watchable. 

It's the music, stupid. 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.