Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

The law and its miracles ... Party allies selected for judicial elevation in Qld ... Justice Jenni Hill's brother ... More entries for the Golden Tortoise award ... Federal Court muddles the maths, again ... Theodora reports ... Read more >>

Politics Media Law Society


Rupert World ... Lord Moloch’s pal Doug the Diva – driving Washington spare … News UK’s model for unionism … What next for the Washington Post? … Concealed coal lobbyists running an anti-Teal campaign … More corruption busting for Stinging Nettle … The litigation industry spawned by Lehrmann ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Party time for Dicey ... Heydon's book - a pathway to rehabilitation ... The predatory man and the clever intellect - all wrapped up in the one person ... Academic tome and cancel agenda ... Despite the plaudits the record of abuse doesn't vanish ... Book launch with young associates at a safe distance ... Procrustes thinks out loud ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


The Lubyanka ... Bullying investigation into former Federal Court judge goes nowhere ... "Complaint unsubstantiated" ... Phew! ... Recommendations about staff education ... Nothing recommended for judicial induction ... More >> 

 

Justinian's Bloggers

Governance turmoil at Tiny Town Law Society ... Night of the long knives ... Lakeside in Canberra ... ACT Law Society upheaval over governance changes ... Bodies carted out of the council room ... Blood on the carpet ... Fraught litigation another distraction ... From Gang Gang ... Read more >> 

"We're in unchartered territory here. A Pope hasn't died before during an Australian election campaign."  

Jane Norman, National Affairs Correspondent, ABC News ... April 21, 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Letter from Rome ... Judges on strike ... Too much "reform" ... Berlusconi legacy ... Referendum on the way ... Constitutional court inflames the Meloni regime with decision on boat people ... Insults galore ... Silvana Olivetti reports ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Tea is for Tippy ... Life of a tiffstaff ... Bright, ambitious and, when it comes to the crucial things, hopeless ... Milking the glory of the gig ...  Introducing Tippy, our new blogger filing from within the concrete cage at Queens Square ... From Justinian's Archive, March 15, 2010 ...  Read more >> 


 

 

« Fish without bicycles | Main | War on wig spitters »
Thursday
Sep152011

The end of the Good Samaritan

China's new "value" system ... Self-interest reigns ... The government says aiding people in distress could cause problems ... Stand back, don't interfere ... Percy Lo-Kit Chan reports from Hong Kong 

A number of recent cases have revealed a worrying trend on the Mainland where kindness to others, and devotion to the elderly, are both strong Confucian values.

On two occasions, the Good Samaritan has been accused by the "victim" of causing the problem in the first place.

This phenomenon is said to be caused by the new prevailing "value" system, which says that you would never spontaneously, or voluntarily, help another person without some ulterior motive.

Sociologists, I think, would say that "social trust" has broken down. The problem has been exacerbated by a new guidebook issued by the Ministry of Health (running to 41-pages).

It mischievously suggests that aiding old people by offering overly hasty assistance may, in fact, hasten their demise. 

Last week, in Hubei, an 88-year-old man collapsed on the pavement. He was surrounded by a crowd on onlookers, none of whom called for emergency services. He remained untreated for about 90 minutes until his son and his wife reached him.

Unfortunately, he died from suffocation caused by a nose-bleed that blocked his airways.

The onlookers seemed to have been afraid that if they intervened they would in some way have been blamed for his collapse, and liable to compensate him.

Don't helpAnd perhaps they were right.

In Zhaoqing, Guangdong, a young man on a motor bike went to the aid of an old lady who had fallen from her bicycle.

After he had offered his aid, the woman accused him of causing her to fall.

Her son-in-law arrived and, declining all explanation, allegedly said:

"Why did you try to help while others did not? How come you helped here if you did not cause her fall? The good-hearted people are long dead!"

For three days the Good Samaritan, on leave from work, sought onlookers, or witnesses who could testify to what had occurred.

It was only after the police told the old lady that they were going through traffic film to trace her route, that she recanted her tale, and admitted that he had had nothing to do with her spill.

Most civil law countries adopt a doctrine that it is a criminal offence not to go to the assistance of someone in danger.

I well remember on a recent trip to your Sydney confronting two attractive women in Oxford Street who were endeavouring to assist a man well in his cups, and passed out on the footpath.

Civil Liability Act may protect youI got out my phone to call the constabulary, but they said they had already done so.

They said they were from France, where you are criminally liable for leaving someone in a distressed position if you can do something about it without danger to yourself.

Sections 56 and 57 of your estimable Civil Liability Act 2002, NSW, confers a protection on the Good Samaritan, provided that the Samaritan has not caused the injury in the first place.

It would seem high time that something similar was introduced on the Mainland. 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.