Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Balkan intrigues ... Old coppers stagger into the Croatian Six inquiry ... 15-year jail terms in 1980 for alleged terrorism ... Miscarriage of justice under review ... Verballing ... Loading-up ... Old fashioned detective "work" ... Evidence so far ... Hamish McDonald reports ... Read more >> 

Politics Media Law Society


Cohn Man ... The ghost of Roy Cohn and the remaking of politics … Cancelling The Apprentice … Anticipatory obedience … NACC Major General’s partially apprehended … Stickler for rectitude … Meretricious sexual services ... Read on ... 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Blue sky litigation ... Another costly Lehrmann decision ... One more spin on the never-never ... Arguable appeal discovered in the bowels of the Gazette of Law & Journalism ... Odious litigants ... Could Lee J have got it wrong on the meaning of rape? ... Calpurnia reports from the Defamatorium ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Qld Bar 'n Grill announces eight new KCs for 2024 ... Details >>

Justinian's Bloggers

London Calling ... Vitamin D deficiency ... Anti-vax solicitor birched for "friendly warning" to schools ... Budget measures hit private school fee payers and their personal jets ... Robing room "humour" ... Equality and sensitivity training missing in action ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt reports from Blighty ... Read more >> 

"Calls to produce scalps publicly and promptly are unhelpful."  

Major Gen. Paul Brereton, Commissioner of the National Corruption Concealment Commission, defending his secretive and snail paced agenda ... Speaking in Adelaide at a Public Sector Governance Forum ... November 15, 2024  ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Vale Percy Allan AM ... Obit for friend and fellow-traveller ... Prolific writer on economics and politics ... Public finance guru ... Technocrat with humanity and broad interests ... Theatre ... Animals ... Art ... Read more ... 


Justinian's archive

A triumph for Victorian morality ... Ashton v Pratt ... In the sack with Dick Pratt ... Meretricious sexual services renders contract void on public policy grounds ... Justice Paul Brereton applies curious moral standard ... A whiff of hypocrisy ... Doubtful finding ... Artemus Jones reporting ... From Justinian's Archive, January 24, 2012 ... Who knew the NACC commissioner had strong views on the sanctity of marriage ... Read more ... 


 

 

« The bias in favour of complexity | Main | Sinking of the Voyager survivors »
Monday
Jun132011

The vulture flies to Beijing

Rule of law in Hong Kong rudely shaken ... Sovereign debt case sent by Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal to National People's Congress for resolution ... Legal system on the mainland still an adjunct of the government ... Percy Lo-Kit Chan reports

The Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal has delivered its long awaited judgment involving the "vulture" fund and the Hong Kong debt (recently discussed here).

In brief, the "vulture" was trying to recover a sovereign debt of the Democratic Republic of the Congo that had been assigned to it, by recovering part of the amount from an entity with assets in Hong Kong, which owed a debt to the Congo.

It reads rather like a rather tricky question under s.9 of the Law Amendment Reform (Consolidation) Ordinance (LARCO) - which is s.12 of the Conveyancing Act, 1919 (NSW) and cognate legislation to you down south.

The HKCFA has now split 3:2 in favour of remitting the question of sovereign immunity involved in the issue to the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.

Under the Basic Law the SCNPC has power to give its "opinion" on the question of jurisdiction and the like of Hong Kong courts.

Chan, and Ribeiro PJJ, and Sir Anthony Mason NPJ agreed that the matter should be referred to the NPC.

Significantly, this is the first time that the court itself has referred a question to the NPC.

As Bokhary PJ noted:

"It has always been known that the day would come when the court has to give a decision on judicial independence. That day has come."

The very extensive judgments which range widely over difficult questions of international law can be found sub nomine Democratic Republic of the Congo and others v FG Hemisthere Associates LLC - [2011] HKCFA 43; FACV000007/2010, 8 June 2011.

The basic question is a fundamental one: does a sovereign body in Hong Kong which engages in a commercial pursuit enjoy only "limited" immunity (the British and Australian position) or "absolute" immunity (what appears to be the PRC position)?

The topic is made more complicated because it would seem that the PRC had some proposed legislation that would have resolved matters as far back as 2002, but for whatever reason it has never been progressed, or promulgated.

Involved, ultimately of course, is the question of "judicial independence" - Hong Kong is part of China albeit a "Special Administrative Region".

Is the question of enforcement of a judgment against another sovereignty entity a matter for the central government, or may a Hong Kong court ultimately resolve it?

Predictably, liberal commentators have been expressing concern about what this reference means for the "rule of law" in Hong Kong.

Many local practitioners are wary of the legal system over the border, most particularly because it still seems to operate as an adjunct to the executive arm of the government with a view to strengthening the development of "Chinese socialism".

On the other hand, the joint judgment of the majority noted (at [181]) the concept of "one country two systems", limiting questions of foreign affairs to the central government.

Is the domination of the executive any the less in developed "democracies" where the it may commit the country to war without a vote or even a full debate in the House of Commons or the House of Representatives?

We will now expectantly await events - the question of the interplay of the central government's authority, and the ultimate independence of the courts of the HKSAR, was bound to arise.

The powerful arguments mounted on both sides show that the ultimate "opinion" of the standing committee will not be an easy one.

 

Percy Lo-Kit Chan reporting from Hong Kong

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.